Switching your mortgage to another bank or to a fixed rate: subrogation and novation

- Subrogation is changing bank; novation is changing the terms with the same bank
- The law caps fees, especially when moving from variable to fixed
- Before deciding, compare the real saving with the cost of switching
If your mortgage costs you more than it should, you can consider changing its terms or moving it to another bank. They are two different operations with similar names. Here is how they work and when they pay off.
Subrogation: changing bank
In a subrogation, another lender pays off your debt to your current bank and becomes your new creditor, on the terms you have negotiated with it. It is the route when you find a clearly better offer elsewhere. The new bank presents its offer and handles the paperwork, and it usually bears the notary, administrative agent and registry costs of the new deed.
Novation: changing the terms with your bank
In a novation you stay with your bank, but you amend the contract: the interest rate, the term or the spread. It is simpler and quicker, although you depend on your bank agreeing to improve your terms. A competing written offer helps a lot.
What fees can be charged
For mortgages signed under Law 5/2019 (since June 2019), the limits on the early repayment fee, which is the one that applies when you change bank, are:
- Variable: up to 0.25% of the outstanding capital during the first three years or up to 0.15% during the first five, depending on the agreed scheme; after that, nothing.
- Fixed: up to 2% during the first ten years and 1.5% from the eleventh.
- From variable to fixed: the limit is very low, 0.05% during the first three years and none afterwards, under current regulations.
For mortgages prior to 2019, what is agreed in your deed applies, within the limits of the earlier rules. These are maximums: the bank may charge less or nothing.
How to tell if it pays off
- Look at your deed and find the rate, spread, remaining term and fees.
- Calculate the monthly saving with the new payment and multiply it by the years you have left.
- Subtract the costs: the fee to your current bank, the valuation (usually paid by the customer) and any linked products.
- Weigh your peace of mind: if you worry about rising Euribor, moving to fixed can give you security even if the payment is similar. I cover it in this Euribor analysis.
With a payment, for example, €90 a month lower for 20 years, the saving can be significant, but only if the costs of switching are reasonable. That is why it is wise to do the numbers with your case and not with generic examples. You can start with improving your mortgage.
When it usually doesn't pay off
- You have few years left and the outstanding capital is small.
- The new offer requires many expensive linked products.
- The difference in rate is minimal.
The fee figures are indicative and must be checked against your deed and current regulations. For legal questions, WeLegal can help you.
Frequently asked questions
How long does it take to switch my mortgage to another bank?
It depends on the lenders and the documentation. Preparing it in advance shortens the process.
Can I switch to fixed if my mortgage is old?
Usually yes, although the terms depend on what you signed. We review your deed to see which fee could apply.
Who pays for the new deed?
In a subrogation, the lender granting the new loan usually bears the notary, administrative agent and registry; the valuation is normally paid by the customer.
Send me your deed and I will work out the real numbers, with no obligation. Message me on WhatsApp.